Competition
England FA Cup
Kick-off
Sat 3 Oct WAT
Status
Full time
HomeBuxtonLWWWL
0:2HT 0–1
AwaySouth ShieldsWLWWL
1 · Buxton30%
X · Draw20%
2 · South Shields50%

Buxton vs South Shields prediction — Over 2.5

Ask Scout about this matchIs it safe? Over 2.5? Both teams to score?

Ask ScoutSafe to bank?
Our tipLost ✗
Over 2.5Over 2.5 goals
PS Score
66
Price
1.50
Fair price
1.53
Edge
-2%
Likeliest score
1–2

1.5 from Buxton plus 2.0 from South Shields makes 3.5 expected goals. It lands 66% of the time in our table. The bookmaker's 1.50 is close to our fair price.

Prices against our chances

Fair = 100 ÷ our chance · edge = how far the price beats it
MarketPickPriceOur chanceFairEdge
Match result1 · Buxton3.0030%3.34-10%
X · Draw3.5020%4.94-29%
2 · South Shields2.0050%2.010%
Double chance1X1.6750%1.99-16%
121.2280%1.25-3%
X21.3070%1.43-9%
Goals 1.5Over 1.5–87%1.15–
Under 1.5–13%7.56–
Goals 2.5Over 2.5 desk1.5066%1.53-2%
Under 2.52.5034%2.90-14%
Goals 3.5Over 3.5–47%2.12–
Under 3.5–53%1.89–
Both teams to scoreGG–58%1.71–
NG–42%2.40–
Half-time result1 HT3.2526%3.85-16%
X HT2.5036%2.81-11%
2 HT2.5038%2.60-4%

Prices are the ones in our data when this page was built and move all day – check your bookmaker before you bet. 18+.

Quick tickets

Ade Ola · PunterScore

Who the numbers favour

Slightly more of the probability sits with South Shields (50%) than with Buxton (30%).

Form going in

Buxton, last six: L W W W L W – four wins. Latest: away at South Shields, 0–4. Scoring 1.8 and conceding 1.7 per game.

South Shields, last six: L W W L W W – four wins. Latest: away at Brackley Town, 2–3. 2.7 goals a game is a strong return. 3 clean sheets in that run.

When they last met

Most recently (Sep 2026) it finished South Shields 4–0 Buxton. Old results count for little in the model – current strength does the work.

Goals

We expect 1.5 goals from Buxton and 2.0 from South Shields, about 3.5 in all. Goals look likely – 66% for Over 2.5, 58% for both sides to score.

Scout's pick (graded)

Before kick-off PunterScore went with Over 2.5 (Over 2.5 goals), PS Score 66 at a price near 1.50 – fair would be 1.53. If you want one scoreline, ours is Buxton 1–2 South Shields. Graded on the 90-minute score. 18+, stake only spare money.

Same day, same competition

League page

Scout answers: Buxton vs South Shields

Who did Scout think would win Buxton vs South Shields?

Before kick-off our numbers had Buxton 30%, draw 20%, South Shields 50%. South Shields had the edge, but it is far from certain.

What is Scout's pick for Buxton vs South Shields?

Over 2.5 (Over 2.5 goals) with a PS Score of 66, priced around 1.50. PS 66 means picks like this win about 66 times in 100.

How many goals did Scout expect in Buxton vs South Shields?

Scout expected about 3.5 goals: Over 2.5 at 66%, Over 1.5 at 87%.

Will both teams score in Buxton vs South Shields?

Both teams to score (GG) comes out at 58% – likely.

What is the likeliest score in Buxton vs South Shields?

Buxton 1–2 South Shields – though any single exact score is always unlikely.

What time is Buxton vs South Shields?

15:00 WAT on Saturday 3 October 2026 (FA Cup).